The Rev. Mr. Elijah Mason, 1766"

The Rev. Mr. James Richards, 1767"

The Rev. Mr. Samuel Hopkins, 1769"

The Rev. Mr. Samuel Munson (1770 – 1793)

The Rev. Dr. Samuel Shepard (1795 – 1846)

The Rev. Dr. Henry Neill (1846 – 1854)

The Rev. Dr. Edmund K. Alden (1854 – 1859)

The Rev. Mr. Reuben S. Kendall (1860 – 1865)

The Rev. Mr. George Muir Smith (1865 – 1871)

The Rev. Mr. Samuel H. Tolman (1872 – 1873)

The Rev. Dr. Charles H. Parkhurst (1874 – 1880)

The Rev. Dr. R. Dewitt Mallary (1880 – 1889)

The Rev. Mr. Edward Day (1890 – 1898)

The Rev. Dr. Frederick Lynch (1899 – 1904)

The Rev. Mr. Clayton J. Potter (1904 – 1907)

The Rev. Mr. Leon D. Bliss (1909 – 1917)

The Rev. Mr. Benson N. Wyman (1918 – 1927)

The Rev. Dr. Hubert Stafford (1927 – 1932)

The Rev. Mr. Edward A. Driscoll (1932 – 1941)

The Rev. Mr. J. Herbert Owen (1942 – 1952)

The Rev. Dr. Harry Trust (1953 – 1959)

The Rev. Mr. David E. Moore (1959 – 1965)

The Rev. Mr. Harris B. Hinchcliff (1966 – )

The Rev. Mr. Robert R. Kyte

The Rev. Mr. Alan Macy (interim)

The Rev. Douglas Moschetta Clark

The Rev. Ms. Julia Aldrich (interim)

The Rev. Ms. Jane Arst Powell

The Rev. Ms. Susanna Crolius (interim)

The Rev. Mr. Robert L. Livingston (interim)

The Rev. Ms. Natalie Shiras (– 2015)

The Rev. Mr. Richard Noel Chrisman (2015 – 2016)

The Rev. Dr. John A. Nelson, 2016 - 2019"

The Rev. Elizabeth R. Goodman