The Rev. Mr. Elijah Mason, 1766

•

The Rev. Mr. James Richards, 1767

•

The Rev. Dr. John A. Nelson, 2016 - 2019

The Rev. Mr. Samuel Hopkins, 1769

The Rev. Mr. Samuel Munson (1770 – 1793)

•

The Rev. Dr. Samuel Shepard (1795 – 1846)

•

The Rev. Dr. Henry Neill (1846 – 1854)

•

The Rev. Dr. Edmund K. Alden (1854 – 1859)

The Rev. Mr. Reuben S. Kendall (1860 – 1865)

•

The Rev. Mr. George Muir Smith (1865 – 1871)

•

The Rev. Mr. Samuel H. Tolman (1872 – 1873)

•

The Rev. Dr. Charles H. Parkhurst (1874 – 1880)

The Rev. Dr. R. Dewitt Mallary (1880 – 1889)

•

The Rev. Mr. Edward Day (1890 – 1898)

•

The Rev. Dr. Frederick Lynch (1899 – 1904)

•

The Rev. Mr. Clayton J. Potter (1904 – 1907)

•

The Rev. Mr. Leon D. Bliss (1909 – 1917)

•

The Rev. Mr. Benson N. Wyman (1918 – 1927)

•

The Rev. Dr. Hubert Stafford (1927 – 1932)

•

The Rev. Mr. Edward A. Driscoll (1932 – 1941)

•

The Rev. Mr. J. Herbert Owen (1942 – 1952)

The Rev. Dr. Harry Trust (1953 – 1959)

•

The Rev. Mr. David E. Moore (1959 – 1965)

•

The Rev. Mr. Harris B. Hinchcliff (1966 – )

•

The Rev. Mr. Robert R. Kyte

The Rev. Mr. Alan Macy (interim)

•

The Rev. Douglas Moschetta Clark

•

The Rev. Ms. Julia Aldrich (interim)

•

The Rev. Ms. Jane Arst Powell

•

The Rev. Ms. Susanna Crolius (interim)

•

The Rev. Mr. Robert L. Livingston (interim)

•

The Rev. Ms. Natalie Shiras (– 2015)

The Rev. Mr. Richard Noel Chrisman (2015 – 2016)

The Rev. Elizabeth R. Goodman